(re: Am I just a wimp?)
The first Phantasmagoria scared me, along with (dont’ ask) Alone in the Dark 1 and Resident Evil 1 (on the Saturn). Strangely, there are a only a handful of games that scare me (The 7th Guest, and it’s not scary), most of which aren’t scary at all. It usually has something that disgusts me. But the first Phantas . . . oh man . . . it gives me the willies!